“Dude,” Sam whispered.

“What?” Dean whispered back.

“You stole my line.”

Dean snorted. “If you remember that, you remember that Halbarad dies on the Pelennor.”

Sam shrugged. “This is movie-verse. We’re not even supposed to be here in this version.” He paused. “’Course, this could be that AU where Halbarad lives and he’s married to a surgeon....”

“Nah, the brother’s name was Thalguron,” Dean replied before realizing that he had just admitted to knowing not only both the book and the movie but also a damn fanfic to the point of being able to distinguish trivia and actually cite lines.

Sam gave him a knowing look.

“Shut up.”